Elep

# Diagnostic Tooling Support Tiers

Diagnostic tooling is important to the consumers of Node.js. It is used both
in development and in production in order to investigate problems.  The failure
of one of these tools may be as big a problem for an end user as a bug within
the runtime itself.

The Node.js project has assessed the tools and the APIs which support those
tools. Each of the tools and APIs has been put into one of
the following tiers.

* Tier 1 - Must always be working(CI tests passing) for all
  Current and LTS Node.js releases. A release will not be shipped if the test
  suite for the tool/API is not green. To be considered for inclusion
  in this tier it must have a good test suite and that test suite and a job
  must exist in the Node.js CI so that it can be run as part of the release
  process.  Tests on master will be run nightly when possible to provide
  early warning of potential issues.  No commit to the current and LTS
  release branches should break this tool/API if the next major release
  is within 1 month. In addition:
    * The maintainers of the tool must remain responsive when there
      are problems;
    * The tool must be actively used by the ecosystem;
    * The tool must be heavily depended on;
    * The tool must have a guide or other documentation in the Node.js GitHub
      organization or website;
    * The tool must be working on all supported platforms;
    * The tool must only be using APIs exposed by Nodejs as opposed to
      its dependencies; and
    * The tool must be open source.

* Tier 2 - Must be working(CI tests passing) for all
  LTS releases. An LTS release will not be shipped if the test
  suite for the tool/API is not green. To be considered for inclusion
  in this tier it must have a good test suite and that test suite and a job
  must exist in the Node.js CI so that it can be run as part of the release
  process. In addition:
    * The maintainers of the tool must remain responsive when
      there are problems;
    * The tool must be actively used by the ecosystem;
    * The tool must be heavily depended on;
    * The tool must have a guide or other documentation in the Node.js GitHub
      organization or website;
    * The tool must be open source.

* Tier 3 - If possible its test suite
   will be run at least nightly in the Node.js CI and issues opened for
   failures.  Does not block shipping a release.

* Tier 4 - Does not block shipping a release.

* Unclassified - tool/API is new or does not have the required testing in the
   Node.js CI in order to qualify for a higher tier.

The choice of which tier a particular tool will be assigned to, will be a
collaborative decision between Diagnostics WG and Release WG. Some of the
criteria considered might be:

* If the tool fits into a key category as listed below.
* Whether the tool is actively used by the ecosystem.
* The availability of alternatives.
* Impact to the overall ecosystem if the tool is not working.
* The availability of reliable test suite that can be integrated into our CI.
* The availability of maintainer or community collaborator who will help
  resolve issues when there are CI failures.
* If the tool is maintained by the Node.js Foundation GitHub organization.

The current categories of tools/APIs that fall under these Tiers are:

* FFDC (F) - First failure data capture, easy to consume initial diagnostic
  information.
* Tracing (T) - use of logging to provide information about execution flow.
* Memory (M) - tools that provide additional information about memory
  used in the Heap or by native code.
* Profiling (P) - tools that provide additional information about where
  CPU cycles are being spent.
* AsyncFlow (A) - tools that provide additional insight into asynchronous
  execution flow.

## Adding a tool to this list

Any tool that might be used to investigate issues when running Node.js can
be added to the list. If there is a new tool that should be added to the
list, it should start by being added to the "Not yet classified" or
"Tier 4" lists. Once it has been added to the list "promotion" to Tier 3
through Tier 1 requires that the requirements listed above be met AND
have agreement from Diagnostics WG and Release WG based on the criteria
listed above.

## Tiers

The tools are currently assigned to Tiers as follows:

## Tier 1

## Tier 2

## Tier 3

| Tool Type | Tool/API Name                        | Regular Testing in Node.js CI | Integrated with Node.js | Target Tier |
 |-----------|--------------------------------------|-------------------------------|-------------------------|-------------|
 | Profiling | V8 CPU profiler                      | Partial (V8 Tests)            | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Profiling | --prof/--prof-process flags          | Yes                           | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Profiling | V8 CodeEventHandler API              | Partial (V8 Tests)            | Yes                     |     2       |
 | Profiling | V8 --interpreted-frames-native-stack | Yes                           | Yes                     |     2       |
 | Profiling | Linux perf                           | Yes                           | Partial                 |     2       |

## Tier 4

## Not yet classified

| Tool Type | Tool/API Name             | Regular Testing in Node.js CI | Integrated with Node.js | Target Tier |
 |-----------|---------------------------|-------------------------------|-------------------------|-------------|
 | FFDC      | node-report               | No                            | No                      |     1       |
 | Memory    | mdb_V8                    | No                            | No                      |     4       |
 | Memory    | node-heapdump             | No                            | No                      |     2       |
 | Memory    | V8 heap profiler          | No                            | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Memory    | V8 sampling heap profiler | No                            | Yes                     |     1       |
 | AsyncFlow | Async Hooks (API)         | ?                             | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Debugger  | V8 Debug protocol (API)   | No                            | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Debugger  | Command line Debug Client | ?                             | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Debugger  | llnode                    | ?                             | No                      |     2       |
 | Debugger  | Chrome Dev tools          | ?                             | No                      |     3       |
 | Debugger  | Chakracore - time-travel  | No                            | Data source only        | too early   |
 | Tracing   | trace_events (API)        | No                            | Yes                     |     1       |
 | Tracing   | DTrace                    | No                            | Partial                 |     3       |
 | Tracing   | LTTng                     | No                            | Removed?                |     N/A     |
 | Tracing   | ETW                       | No                            | Partial                 |     3       |
 | Tracing   | Systemtap                 | No                            | Partial                 |     ?       |
 | Profiling | DTrace                    | No                            | Partial                 |     3       |
 | Profiling | Windows Xperf             | No                            | ?                       |     ?       |
 | Profiling | 0x                        | No                            | No                      |     4       |
 | Profiling | node-clinic               | No                            | No                      | too early   |
 | F/P/T     | appmetrics                | No                            | No                      |     ?       |
 | M/T       | eBPF tracing tool         | No                            | No                      |     ?       |